Finding the Right Sports Mentor or Coach for Your Teen

Book a

Complimentary Call

With One Of Our Certified Teen Experts Who WIll Help You Come Up With A Success Game Plan For Your Teen!

BOOK YOUR CALL TODAY!

How to Find the Right Sports Mentor or Coach

Finding the right sports mentor and coach for your teen can make a profound difference in their life—both on and off the field. More than just guiding physical skill development, the right mentor helps teens develop resilience, confidence, and mental focus. In a competitive sports environment, mental toughness for young athletes is often the factor that determines not just who wins, but who keeps going when it’s hard.

A mentor offers more than instruction—they build character. Whether your teen struggles with pressure, confidence, or consistency, a great coach or mentor can help them push past self-doubt and start believing in their potential. This article will guide you in understanding what to look for, how to find the right person, and how mentoring ties into personal growth.

Why a Mentor or Coach Matters for Your Teen Athlete

sports coach talking to young teen athlete on the track field

A coach can teach skills, but a mentor builds the person behind the player. Teens with strong mentorship relationships are more likely to stay engaged in sports, develop leadership qualities, and build lasting confidence. According to the Search Institute, teens with mentors are 55% more likely to enroll in college and report better emotional regulation.

The right mentor helps your teen:

  • Stay motivated during challenging seasons
  • Handle failure and success with grace
  • Build long-term discipline and self-respect
  • Develop both athletic and life skills

Importantly, a mentor gives your teen someone outside the family to turn to—someone who can encourage them through rough patches, model resilience, and reinforce the values you teach at home.

You can explore more on this idea in our post Why Every Teen Deserves a Mentor.

Mentor vs. Coach: Understanding the Difference

Although people often use these terms interchangeably, there’s a clear difference. A coach focuses on performance—practices, drills, game strategy. A mentor offers guidance on personal growth, mental resilience, and long-term mindset.

Still, the two roles can—and ideally should—overlap. The best coaches also serve as mentors, combining structure with support.

Here’s how they differ:

  • A coach sets physical goals; a mentor helps with mental and emotional ones
  • A coach may work with a team; a mentor builds a one-on-one bond
  • A mentor stays consistent even beyond a season, sometimes becoming a lifelong advisor

Some families also consider a life coach for teenagers. This can be especially valuable if your teen needs broader support—managing pressure, building motivation, or balancing school and sports.

For a breakdown of which is right for your child, read Life Coach vs. Mentor: What’s the Difference and How to Choose.

Building Mental Toughness Through Mentorship

Sports Coach Building Mental Toughness Through Mentorship

Sports are filled with adversity: tough losses, injuries, pressure moments. The difference between athletes who rise and those who falter often comes down to mindset.

A great mentor helps your teen develop mental toughness—the ability to bounce back, focus, and persevere. These aren’t just buzzwords. They’re skills that can be taught and strengthened.

Mentors do this by:

  • Teaching mental toughness exercises for athletes like deep breathing, positive visualization, and goal-setting
  • Modeling a growth mindset—encouraging teens to see effort as the path to success
  • Normalizing mistakes and losses as learning opportunities

In our Parent’s Guide to Boosting Mental Toughness in Young Athletes, we walk through specific strategies you can use at home. But a mentor reinforces these lessons in real-time—on the field, in the gym, or during post-game debriefs.

Mentors often share mental toughness examples from their own careers or well-known athletes to inspire your teen. Think of Serena Williams playing through injury or Simone Biles choosing mental health over medals. These stories give teens a model for strength and self-awareness.

The Mentor’s Role in Building Confidence and Character

Confidence is not something teens either have or don’t—it’s something that grows through consistent reinforcement and personal wins. A mentor helps your teen rack up those wins—not just points on a scoreboard, but emotional breakthroughs.

Here’s how mentors help:

  • Encouraging risk-taking and stepping out of comfort zones
  • Providing real-time feedback that builds, not breaks
  • Celebrating small improvements, not just big achievements

You’ll often see a shy teen start to speak up more. Or a frustrated player begin to channel that energy into focused practice. These are signs of healthy mentorship at work.

This kind of support builds more than confidence. It builds character—discipline, patience, humility, leadership. We dive deeper into these transformations in our post on Proven Strategies to Help Your Teen Build Confidence and Succeed in Life.

What to Look For in a Mentor or Coach

Choosing the right person requires more than checking a resume. You’re looking for someone who will help your teen grow—not just perform.

Key traits to look for include:

  • Experience with youth development: Someone who understands teen psychology and knows how to communicate with young people
  • Empathy and patience: They should encourage effort over perfection and listen before they give advice
  • Clear values and boundaries: The mentor should model the qualities you want your teen to adopt—respect, work ethic, positivity
  • Consistent availability: Growth takes time. A mentor who shows up consistently builds trust and long-term impact

Observe how your teen responds to them after a trial session. Do they feel seen? Encouraged? Challenged in the right way?

Also, make sure the coach understands your teen’s goals—whether it’s earning a scholarship or simply feeling more confident.

Where to Find the Right Mentor or Coach

Mentors don’t always come from traditional sources. Here are some places to start:

  • School teams and coaches: Many assistant coaches or even older athletes serve as informal mentors
  • Community centers and sports clubs: Organizations like YMCA or local leagues often have mentor programs
  • Online platforms: For broader options or specialties like mindset training, virtual mentoring is a growing field

When evaluating options, consider their coaching philosophy. Do they emphasize winning—or learning? Competition—or development?

A great place to begin if you’re considering virtual mentorship is our post on How to Choose an Online Life Coach for Your Teen.

Importantly, involve your teen in the process. Let them meet potential mentors, ask questions, and share how they feel. This ensures they feel empowered—not managed.

Lasting Benefits: Sports Mentorship Builds a Champion Mindset

The benefits of sports mentoring extend well beyond the field:

  • Improved academic focus and time management
  • Higher resilience to social stress and anxiety
  • Greater independence and leadership in peer groups
  • Confidence in handling real-world challenges

Many parents tell us they see a change not just in sports, but in how their teen speaks to others, handles disappointment, and sets goals for the future.

One study from MENTOR National found that 74% of young adults who had mentors say those relationships helped them become more confident and hopeful about the future. That’s powerful.

With the right support, your teen can develop a mindset that serves them for life—not just for the next season.

Empower Your Teen’s Growth With the Right Support

Your teen’s journey in sports is about so much more than competition. It’s about personal growth, mindset, and the relationships that help shape who they become.

By finding the right mentor or coach, you’re giving your child tools that will serve them for life: confidence, mental toughness, and a belief in their own potential.

If you’re ready to take that next step, we’d love to support you.

➡️ Learn more about The Attitude Advantage Teen Coaching Program — our personalized, proven approach to helping teens thrive.
➡️ Have questions? Contact our team — we’re here to help.

Let’s find the right coach or mentor to bring out the best in your teen—on and off the field.

BOOK A COMPLEMENTARY CALL TODAY!

Visit our Teen Program page To learn how you can get life coaching for your teen
Click to learn more

About The Founder

Jesse LeBeau is one of the top youth motivational speakers and teen coaches today. He has inspired over 1M+ teens live from stage and helped over 250,000 teenagers and families with his teen, parent and school programs. His new reality series ‘TEAM UP’ follows him as he tours the country helping kids he meets along the way that need it the most.

Help your teen build more confidence, grit and master their attitude by booking a call with us today!

Related Posts

Categories:

All Posts